How much should a 1 Carat Diamond Ring Cost?

May 08, 2019

what does a 1 carat diamond ring cost

This is probably the one of the most common questions I get. Since a 1 carat diamond ring is the most popular size for engagement rings it stands to reason that when making such an important investment you know exactly how much you should be spending.

Art Deco Baguette Engagement Ring


The cost of a 1 carat diamond ring? What should I expect to pay?

There is a short answer and a long answer to this question. If you are just talking about the diamond you should expect to pay anywhere from $4500 to $6500 for a 1 carat diamond ring of respectable quality. Now that takes into account the ever important 5 C’s of diamond buying- The Clarity, Cut, Carat, Color and if it is certified or not.

Now that does not mean you couldn’t find yourself a 1 carat diamond ring for $2500 or even $3000, but it will most likely be lacking in one of the ever so important C’s. For example it may have a big black inclusion in the center of the table for everyone to see.

It may be extremely cloudy which falls under Clarity on the scale. When a diamond is cloudy it will appear dull and lifeless which defeats the whole purpose of paying for a diamond. When we think of 1 carat diamonds; we think of sparkle, fire and shine. If you diamond is cloudy, you will sacrificing this important quality.

Or it may have a very think girdle, which means that the diamond could chip easily, and thereby render your entire investment worthless since diamonds cannot be glued back together. The only way to fix it would be to have it re-cut in which case the 1 carat diamond that you got such a deal on is now a .50ct diamond. (gulp!) And yes, I have seen that happen. 

 1 carat diamond engagement ring cost

Tips on buying a 1 carat diamond ring

There are many ways to still get a perfectly lovely 1 carat diamond ring all within your budget. You don't want to end up with a diamond that is inferior or problematic down the road, but you don't want to break the bank either. There is a way to strike a balance between the two and make buying a diamond a pleasant experience.

There are various ways of mixing and matching the 5C’s to bring it in for reasonable amount. Perhaps you can go down a grade or two in color if you are having it set in yellow gold.

Or you can search for a SI1 quality diamond where the imperfections are hidden and placed strategically on the stone instead of paying considerably more for a diamond that is a VS1 or VS2. Often this can keep the costs down on a 1 carat diamond, so don’t be afraid of inclusions. They are not all created equal.

So, the best way to keep your 1 carat diamond ring costs reasonable and still feel like your investment is protected is to have someone help you pick out your diamond. We only work with the best diamond dealers who provide us with certified diamonds. At Rough Luxe we also proud to provide ethically sourced diamonds.

We would love to help you pick out a 1 carat diamond for you and also help you design a custom engagement ring. Feel free to contact us about our custom engagement ring process. We would love to hear from you!

Heather Charlick
Heather Charlick

Hello There! I'm Heather-a jewelry artist living with my beloved husband & horses in the rolling hills of Tennessee. I make vintage inspired engagement rings for the romantic bride. I would love to help you custom design your dream ring, so feel free to contact me anytime.

Also in Rough Luxe Jewelry Blog

Grey Diamond East West Ring
East West Grey Diamond Art Deco Engagement Ring

January 15, 2021

I had the pleasure of working with the cutest couple recently to design her Grey Diamond engagement ring. It had an Art Deco flair and was set in a very unique East West setting.
Read More
white gold vs. platinum for an engagement ring
White Gold vs. Platinum for an engagement ring? Which is best

October 10, 2019

White Gold vs. Platinum Engagement Rings - What is the difference? Both can be great options for an engagement ring but it is helpful to know the differences so that you can make the best decision for you.
Read More
should i buy my engagement ring online
Should you buy your engagement ring online?

October 04, 2019

You are ready to pop the big question! But you have no idea where to go to buy that perfect, make their heart sing, ring. The task can be a bit daunting and you are wondering if you should buy your engagement ring online?
Read More

Join our RL Jewel Box